They are plays that will forever be etched in the minds of Cardinal fans.
– James Harrison’s rumbling 100-yard interception return for a touchdown with no time left in the first half, turning a potential Cardinal lead into a 17-7 deficit.
– Larry Fitzgerald’s burst of speed that turned a slant pattern into a 64-yard touchdown romp up the middle of the Steeler defense and a 23-20 lead with 2:37 remaining.
– And, of course, Santonio Holmes’ outstretched, tip-toe catch in the back corner of the end zone with 35 seconds left that sealed the deal on Pittsburgh’s 27-23 victory in Super Bowl XLIII.
They were plays for the ages, but where do they rank among the greatest Super Bowl plays of all time? Do you remember:
– David Tyree’s catch last year in which he trapped a pass from Eli Manning against his helmet, helping to preserve a late Giants’ rally?
– Marcus Allen’s 74-yard TD run in Super Bowl XVIII?
– John Riggins’ game-winning 43-yard run in XVII?
– Mike Jones’ last-second tackle of Kevin Dyson at the 1-yard line with no time left, preserving the Rams’ win in XXXIV?
– Lynn Swann’s acrobatic catch in Super Bowl X?
– Adam Vinatieri’s game-winning field goals in XXXVI and XXXVIII?
– Butch Johnson’s tumbling TD grab for Dallas in XII?
– Joe Montana to John Taylor in XXIII?
– John Elway’s “helicopter dive” in which he scrambled for a first down, got hit and did a 360-spin in the air in XXXII?
– Max McGee’s one-handed stab in Super Bowl I?
– Willie Parker’s 75-yard run in XL?
Here’s my all-time top five. Did I leave one out? Would you rank them differently? Post your top five in the comments section of this blog, or just vote online in our Tribune poll.
5) Harrison’s interception return qualifies for my list in part because it was the longest play in Super Bowl history. More importantly, it completely changed the complexion of the game, turning a possible 14-10 Cardinal lead into a 17-7 Pittsburgh advantage. Watching six different Cardinal players get a hand on Harrison as the 6-foot, 242-pound linebacker rumbled down the sideline, leaping over tacklers, was classic. With no time left, it would have meant much less if he didn’t take it the distance. And Fitzgerald nearly had a chance to stop him if he wouldn’t have run into one of his own bench players, Antrel Rolle, on the sideline as he gave chase and finally hit Harrison at the goal line.
4) At the risk of getting Steeler-heavy in these rankings, there’s just no way to leave out the Swann Dive. Lynn Swann actually had three back-breaking receptions in Super Bowl X, including a 64-yard TD in the fourth quarter that helped Pittsburgh beat Dallas 17-14. But the play Swann is most famous for is one that did not even lead to any points. With the Steelers trailing 10-7 and facing third-and-6 from their own 10-yard line in the second quarter, Terry Bradshaw threw a deep pass toward Swann. Cowboys cornerback Mark went up and tipped the pass as both players went for the ball, but Swann maintained his concentration and leaped forward, juggled the ball, then pulled it in as he stretched out horizontally. Swann, had who surprised many by even playing in the game after suffering a severe concussion in the AFC championship, finished with four receptions for 161 yards and became the first wide receiver ever named MVP in a Super Bowl.
3) If end-of-the-game heroics define a great play, it doesn’t get much better than Jones’ game-saving tackle in Super Bowl XXXIV. The Titans were at the Rams’ 10-yard line and trailed 23-16 with 6 seconds left in the game when Steve McNair threw a slant pass to Dyson, who desperately tried to reach the end zone only to be stopped by Jones as time expired. The play simply became known as “The Tackle.” … By the way, Kurt Warner threw for a Super Bowl-record 414 yards in the game and was named MVP.
2) Tyree’s catch last year at University of Phoenix Stadium was one of those “I can’t believe he caught that” kinds of plays. The Giants trailed, 14-10, and faced third-and-5 from their own 44. Manning went back to pass and almost got sacked by Adalius Thomas of the Patriots but somehow broke away, then threw a prayer toward Tyree. The Giant receiver went up for the pass, got hit by Rodney Harrison and grabbed the ball and trapped it against his helmet, somehow hanging on as he hit the ground. The Giants went on to win 17-14 in the greatest upset in NFL history.
1) It’s easy to over-hype the play that is freshest in your mind. But Holmes’ amazing grab near the end of XLIII is my No. 1. Tyree’s catch was more magnificent, as was Swann’s for that matter. But neither of those resulted in a TD… with 35 seconds left in the game… at the end of a 78-yard drive… and their team in desperation mode trailing by three points. Holmes stretching out in the corner of the end zone to make the grab and toe-tap his feet inbounds was incredible. But Ben Roethlisberger’s throw… over three Cardinal defenders… after pump-faking several times trying to find an open receiver… was one of those plays that he just seems to always make.
